People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Pond Pit BBQ does it right from the moment you walk in the door - fireplace on one and and Franklin stove on the other, providing a cozy environment. Next is the staff who welcome you as soon as you come in. The food is hot and delicious. The owner came out to throw logs on the fireplace and spoke with us for 10 minutes. Great guy with a passion for BBQ. He used his 20 years of construction experience to take a bar that was falling apart and rebuild it. ”
“ Great food and value. You don't want to miss this spot. Food is great! I love this concept ”
“ Wow! An amazing BBQ experience. We have been a few times now and everything has always been great! They make fresh daily and often sell out so make a plan and get there early. ”
“ Delicious food with large servings. Had the brisket poutine, Cuban with a side of tomato cucumber salad and Mac and cheese. Cute place inside. There is no waitstaff you order at a window, but nice seating inside and bar area. We thought food was better than Dinosaur BBQ. ”
“ 4pm Friday on the dot and the smoked Prime Rib is flying out the door with preorders and patrons walking in. All the traditional smoke house sides are there such as beans, Mac and Cheese, and coleslaw etc. This is solid for northern New York and this place is busy on the weekends. Rustic as you would expect on the inside with high tops near the bar and a larger table for groups. The pricing is good and we left stuffed with leftovers ready for us later. Will definitely be back ”
“ Wow!! Got the brisket, wings, slaw and potato salad. It tasted so good I forgot to take a pic.... Some of the best I have had and staff was pleasant. I would stop by for sure if you're near by. ”
“ Still on the camping trek, and haven't gone out in a week to dine out! What is wrong with me?!? ( until last night .... ) Yes, a revisit to The Pond Pit BBQ as it is the closest restaurant to our camp spot. The place was packed, as there was a band playing outside from 4-7 as well. You have to get in a line to order your food. They give you a beeper when it's ready. It didn't take long to get our food. Every Friday, they feature a smoked prime rib that is out of this world. A nice king cut portion, along with 2 sides. They start serving that at 4pm. Get there early, because it doesn't last long. Oh so good. All of the sides we've had so far are amazing too. I enjoy the broccoli salad and the mac n cheese. Janice got the poutine. Tasty gravy and fries with HUGE cheese curd chunks. Look at the portion size!! Once again, a great bbq joint. You need to Check em Out!!! ”
“ I really enjoyed The Pond Pit! As it is a bit of a drive from Syracuse, I made this my first stop of the day before heading to a state park. You order at a window or you can sit at the bar and be served. I sat at the bar and the bartender was efficient and friendly. I ordered the Pig Pen because...I guess it sounded like the best way to try all the things! I wasn't a fan of the white BBQ sauce--I guess it's good they put the sauces on there, per their recommendation. It'll eventually mix in and it'll be fine. I ended up with a TON of leftovers so I think I'll be eating this happily for awhile. I live two blocks away from Dinosaur and I'd rather drive to PP for BBQ cravings. It's the closest thing to true southern style BBQ I've had outside of the south. Would love to see collard greens on their menu though, that would seal my love of this place! ”
“ We've been eating here since they opened and love everything on the menu. Their food is consistently delicious and we miss it when we leave camp for the season. Our favorites are the 1/2 chicken meal and burger but honestly everything is fantastic. Even better now that they've opened the full bar and restaurant. Definitely a gem in the Sandy Pond area! ”
Menu
Smoked Chicken Wings
Chicken, Bacon And Ranch
Chicken Corduban
White Bbq Sauce
Nc Bbq Sauce
About
Pond Pit BBQ
Welcome to Pond Pit BBQ, a hidden gem nestled at 8883 State Rte 3 in Sandy Creek, NY. If you’re searching for an authentic barbecue experience that captures the heart and soul of smoked meats, this spot should top your list. The atmosphere immediately grabs your attention with its cozy setting—equipped with a warm fireplace and an inviting Franklin stove. As soon as you step in, the friendly staff welcomes you, setting the stage for what promises to be a memorable meal.
The menu at Pond Pit BBQ is a carnivore’s delight. With offerings like Full Rack Pork St Louis Ribs, Baby Back Ribs, and brisket prepared to perfection, your taste buds are in for a treat. Not to mention the pulled pork and chicken dishes that embody the true essence of barbecue. Each dish is crafted with care, ensuring that you savor every bite. Local patrons rave about the homemade side dishes, particularly the Mac N Cheese variations that incorporate flavors like Buffalo Chicken and Brisket, each one more delicious than the last.
As highlighted by satisfied customers, such as Jeff S., the passion behind Pond Pit BBQ shines through. The owner invests heart and soul into the experience, right from refurbishing the rustic bar to engaging with the customers. This connection fosters a warm, inviting environment where food is not just a meal but an experience. Whether you’re indulging in a Chicken Caesar Salad or the zesty Black Blue Brisket Salad, the freshness of each dish is a testament to the care put into its preparation.
Not only is the food stellar, but the value is also commendable. As The Retired G. puts it, you simply don’t want to miss this spot if you're in the area. With large servings that can easily leave you stuffed, you might find yourself bringing home a doggy bag. Just like Tina C. noted, you’ll want to arrive early; the freshness of their offerings can mean that they sell out quickly, a true sign of quality and popularity.
Friday evenings are especially bustling, as mentioned by Brian P., with patrons eagerly anticipating the smoked Prime Rib, proving that this BBQ haven holds its weight even against larger competitors. The variety of traditional smokehouse sides such as beans, coleslaw, and, of course, that beloved Mac and Cheese make it a well-rounded experience for any barbecue lover.
So, if you're eager to indulge in some of the best BBQ in northern New York, drop by Pond Pit BBQ. Discover the hearty menu, enjoy the welcoming ambiance, and experience the passion for barbecue that makes every meal extraordinary. Your taste buds will thank you!
Book a table